Rings of Power only matters if it escapes Peter Jackson's shadow
Season 3 brings the One Ring and a full-blown war, but Prime Video's ambitious Tolkien bet pays off only if it builds its own story rather than echoing the films.
Photo: Kevin Paul / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)
Is a Middle-earth series essential if its most exciting moment is the one every fan already knows by heart? That is the uncomfortable question hanging over The Rings of Power as Season 3 approaches. The show has finally reached the forging of the One Ring, the single image the whole franchise is built around. It is also the image most likely to make us think about someone else's movies.
A five-year leap, and a ring that looks like Jackson's
The season premieres on Prime Video on November 11, 2026, with four episodes on day one, two more on November 18 and the last two on November 25, according to SciFiNow. The story jumps five years after the fall of Eregion. Sauron is working from Barad-dûr, and Lindon and Rivendell are among the few places still resisting him. Co-showrunner J.D. Payne puts the change this way: "The first two seasons we built to a big battle. This season we drop you right in the middle of one."
The One Ring itself is the telling detail. Prop master Tina Jones told GamesRadar+ that the design "had to be instantly recognizable to everybody who had watched Peter Jackson's [movies]". So the team kept it, and only made it slightly larger.
The Jackson ring is a trap as much as a gift
The prop team's decision is sensible. Nobody wants a reinvented ring, and we wouldn't either. But it shows the bind the series is in. Every time it wants to land an emotional beat, it borrows the visual grammar of films that arrived long before it. Celeborn is a good example. The character appeared in Jackson's Fellowship of the Ring, and the series now offers a younger version of him played by Jamie Campbell Bower. That is a smart idea only if the younger Celeborn is a person and not a pre-order bonus for nostalgia.
In our view, the show's best argument has never been the ring. It is the stretch of history the films skipped. That means Númenor tearing itself apart, with Míriel now banished and building a resistance against Pharazôn. It means Gandalf finally knowing who he is. It means a Sauron who, as Charlie Vickers puts it, "is haunting himself" over Celebrimbor's legacy. These are stories the films never told, and they can be told only here.
Dropping us into the war is the series' boldest move
Dropping viewers into a war already in progress is a confident choice. In our view, it spares the show another season of slow assembly. We can't say whether it works until we've seen it. Early reactions are unanimously positive, but they are reactions to the first two episodes, and CBR notes that full reviews were still under embargo. Reactions to a screening are a weak signal, so we'd wait for the reviews.
The release format is more interesting than it looks. BuddyTV reports that the co-showrunners pushed for larger batches because they think the overlapping storylines suit sustained viewing. We think that makes sense for a show with this many threads. Weekly drip let each episode be judged alone, and that never helped a series whose pleasures are cumulative. The risk is that three drops in three weeks leave less time for conversation. Prime Video needs conversation, not just completion.
Watch for one thing: does the forging scene belong to this show?
Our verdict is cautious optimism. The scale on screen has never been the issue. The issue is whether the series gives us a reason to watch it that Jackson's trilogy can't provide. If the forging scene is an homage that serves a new story about Sauron's cracks, Númenor's fall and Gandalf's purpose, then Prime Video has finally found its footing. If it becomes a greatest-hits tour of familiar imagery, then it will remain an elaborate companion piece.
If you've skipped the earlier seasons, a recap is enough: Sauron posed as Halbrand and Annatar, Eregion fell, and the Stranger turned out to be Gandalf. Then watch the first batch with one question in mind. When the ring appears, does the scene belong to this show, or to the films? That will tell you more than any trailer.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Planeswalker must win over people who never opened a booster pack
After seven years of false starts, Netflix's Magic: The Gathering series has a name, a hero and a look. Whether it has a story for outsiders is another matter.
Emily in Paris says goodbye, but will Emily ever change?
A Greek-set final season arriving at Christmas makes for a pretty farewell, but the real test is whether Emily grows up instead of just collecting new postcards.
Blade Runner 2099 must stop selling us the rain and start asking questions
The final trailer promises replicant rule, a sunlit Los Angeles and a human who has lost her humanity. That's a better pitch than neon nostalgia, if the series follows through.
Pluribus is Apple's best sci-fi show, and Apple is making us wait
Season 2 of Pluribus is filming, but a long production and post-production road means Apple's prestige-first pace could cost it the buzz it earned.



