Spider-Man's Oscar push is bold, but box office won't carry it
Sony is putting its full weight behind a Best Picture bid for Brand New Day. Money opens the door, but the Academy has never been a cash register.
Photo: Newell Reinvention / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Can the biggest movie of the year also be one of the ten best? Sony thinks the question answers itself. Whether the Academy agrees is another matter, and we suspect the studio is a little too confident.
What Sony is actually betting on
According to Deadline's exclusive, Sony Pictures and Marvel's Spider-Man: Brand New Day is about to launch an all-out campaign for a spot in the Best Picture race at the 99th annual Academy Awards. Tom Rothman, chairman and CEO of Sony Pictures Motion Picture Group, is putting the full weight of the studio behind it. Deadline's headline carries his pitch: "Are You Telling Me There Are 10 Films Better Than This One?"
The numbers are the backbone of that pitch. Deadline describes the film as the highest-grossing movie of this year, and of all time, at the domestic box office, and says it is about $41 million short of becoming the first to reach a billion dollars domestically. GamesRadar adds that an extended edition with seven extra minutes is headed to theaters before Avengers: Doomsday. That is a remarkable résumé, but it is a commercial one.
Rothman's question is rhetorical, and voters don't do rhetoric
The "ten films" line is clever. Best Picture has ten slots, and the argument is that a cultural event of this size deserves one. As a marketing hook, it is smart: it turns a snub into an accusation before anyone has been snubbed.
But we think it confuses popularity with the thing voters reward. The Academy doesn't ask which film sold the most tickets. It asks which film felt like an achievement, with a vision, performances and craft that members want to put their names behind. Box office tells you millions of people showed up. It doesn't tell you a voter will rank the film on a ballot above the quieter, more personal titles that fill most of the category.
Superhero movies have long had a hard time with awards voters, and we see no reason Spider-Man gets a pass just because it is the biggest of them. Being Marvel-adjacent may even work against it. Some voters will probably treat a franchise installment as a product, however well made. And grosses can't settle the question of quality. We can't tell you from the receipts whether the film is good enough, and neither can Sony.
The risk isn't losing, it's looking desperate
A campaign has costs beyond the budget. If Sony pushes hard and the film misses the ten, the story risks becoming "the studio that begged." Rothman has made the attempt very public, so a miss will be public too.
There is an upside. A campaign puts the film in front of members who skipped it, and an extended cut keeps it in the conversation. It may also lift craft categories where the film has a more realistic shot. Our view is that Sony should treat Best Picture as the stretch goal and build the pitch around what the film does best, rather than around its grosses. Let the work argue, not the receipts.
Our verdict
It's a bold play and, honestly, a fun one. Rothman gets credit for swinging. But we'd bet against a nomination, and we'd advise Sony to keep the tone confident rather than entitled. Awards voters tend to bristle at being told what they owe a movie. If Brand New Day gets in, it will be because voters genuinely loved it, not because it was big. Sony's job is to make that case, and the box office is the least persuasive part of it.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Zendaya's Best Actress Push for Dune 3 Is a Bold, Risky Bet
Moving Chani from supporting to lead tests how far Oscar strategy can stretch a category, and it could leave Zendaya with the harshest comparison of her career.
Inde Navarrette's Schiaparelli Moment Cements Her Stardom
Inde Navarrette's bold Schiaparelli choice at the Academy Museum Gala isn't just fashion; it's a calculated move solidifying her status as a multifaceted star poised for lasting Hollywood influence.

