Adam Driver's "criminal" is right: Lucasfilm shelved its best bet
Driver's blunt verdict on The Hunt for Ben Solo exposes a studio that said no to Soderbergh and a beloved character, and has yet to show a clear plan for Star Wars films.
AI-generated image
What does a studio need before it says yes to a Star Wars movie? A beloved character, a star eager to come back and a celebrated director would seem like a decent start. Lucasfilm had all three and still passed. Now Adam Driver has put a word on it: "criminal."
What Driver actually said
In an interview with the Associated Press during the press tour for Paper Tiger, Driver looked back at The Hunt for Ben Solo, the sequel he spent about two and a half years developing with Steven Soderbergh. His line, as IGN reports: "Steven Soderbergh wants to make a Star Wars film. What are we debating? It's what it is. It's criminal. Or it felt criminal."
According to Driver, then-Disney CEO Bob Iger and co-chairman Alan Bergman "didn't see how Ben Solo was alive." Lucasfilm president Dave Filoni has said that, as of August 2026, it isn't something the company is working on. Soderbergh called the decision "insane" and ruled out a return in April, and Driver says "the ship has sailed."
"Criminal" is hyperbole, but the instinct is sound
Let's be fair: nobody committed a crime. Studios pass on scripts every day, and Driver himself softened it with "or it felt criminal." But the underlying frustration is hard to argue with. The one reason on record, from Driver, is that executives couldn't see how a character who died in The Rise of Skywalker was alive.
In our view, that is the least interesting objection a franchise can raise. Star Wars is a universe built on mythology, redemption and things not being what they seem. If the pitch comes from the actor who played the role and one of the most admired directors working, the question shouldn't be "how is he alive?" It should be "what do they know that we don't?" Per TheWrap, the film would allegedly have culminated in Ren's redemption and apparent death, which suggests the story engaged with the problem rather than ignoring it. That's a report, not something we've read, so take it with caution.
A studio with no visible plan punishes its own best bet
The bigger problem, we think, is what this says about Lucasfilm. Taika Waititi's long-gestating Star Wars movie was officially put on ice last month too, per IGN. Two of the more talked-about feature projects are gone, and IGN notes that the franchise's future still has plenty of question marks to address. A few projects are confirmed to launch in the next year, but from the outside this doesn't look like a studio executing a strategy. It looks like one hedging.
Driver's explanation is the most revealing part. He describes a business that is "reactionary," where people are "so risk-averse" and "like to quote metrics based on the most recent thing that made money." We'd say that's the real diagnosis. Chasing the last hit is a way of avoiding a decision, and a franchise that avoids decisions drifts.
And consider what Lucasfilm threw away besides a script. Fans flew a plane over the Disney lot and rented billboards in Times Square, according to TheWrap. Studios spend fortunes trying to manufacture that kind of enthusiasm. Here it appeared on its own, aimed at a film that didn't exist, and it didn't change the outcome. Demand like that is rare, and treating it as noise is a strange way to run a brand.
What to take from it
There's a consolation of sorts. Driver is moving on, with a role as Mister Sinister in Marvel's upcoming X-Men movie, so the Disney relationship isn't scorched earth. And Driver says Soderbergh already has something else that's "one of the best things he's ever written." Good for them.
Our verdict: this is a loss for Star Wars more than for either of them. A studio that can't say yes to a sure thing like this should stop promising fans a bold cinematic future. Until Lucasfilm shows a slate with a point of view, we'd treat every announced Star Wars movie with healthy skepticism. The Ben Solo film that fans rallied behind may not exist, but the lesson is clear: they weren't asking for nostalgia. They were asking for someone to take a risk.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Friday the 13th needs more than Jason's mask to justify a 2027 return
Steve Miner is back, Jason returns to theaters after 18 years, and a prequel series is in the works. The new film is welcome only if it offers more than nostalgia.
Disney's Adobe AI pact is smart, but "artist-led" needs proof
Private models trained on Disney's own IP are a safer bet than a frontier-lab romance. But speed and control only earn trust if Disney says where AI touches the art.
DC's Constantine bet is smart, as long as it forgets Keanu
A Constantine movie written by Evil Dead Wrath's Francis Galluppi suggests DC is ready for real horror. It only works if the studio picks a tone and skips the nostalgia detour.
Disney's hand-drawn return is a smart bet, but one film isn't a revival
Disney is bringing 2D back for a new film, and it's more than nostalgia: a distinct look beats the CGI house style. But the studio has to prove it can do it again.



