Sunrise on the Reaping must prove a prequel can be more than a victory lap
Haymitch's story opens this week to split reviews and big box-office hopes. Prequels only earn their place when they argue something, not when they merely reunite familiar faces.
AI-generated image
Is there any such thing as a prequel nobody asked for that still turns out to be necessary? The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is about to find out. It's a film whose ending we already know, about a man we already met as a drunk, in a world we've already seen burn.
The facts first. Directed by Francis Lawrence, the film follows a teenage Haymitch (Joseph Zada) at the 50th Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, with twice the usual tributes. Ralph Fiennes plays Snow, and younger versions of Effie, Plutarch and Caesar appear. It's the sixth film in the series and opens in US theaters November 20. According to Dark Horizons, box-office estimates (so, a forecast) put the domestic opening at around $105-120 million, while The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes debuted to $44 million. Reviews are mixed: 72% on Rotten Tomatoes and 56/100 on Metacritic at the time of that report.
The box office is betting on brand, and that's the risk
A projection like that says Panem still sells. It doesn't say this film deserves it. We'd argue the gap between those two things is exactly where prequels live or die.
The critics' split is revealing. The Guardian calls it a cash grab for an exhausted franchise, with "no authentic reason to exist." Screen Rant's Alex Harrison, quoted on Rotten Tomatoes' roundup, says the movie is good "in spite of" nostalgia-based storytelling that "constantly threatens to smother it." Those are two very different verdicts, but they share a diagnosis: the fan-service machinery is the film's biggest threat.
We think that diagnosis is right, and that it's the right test. Seeing a younger Effie or a younger Caesar is a party trick. It lasts about as long as the first reveal. Matt Goldberg's line that it's "more of a curiosity than a reason to play the games again" stings because it describes what most prequels actually are.
Haymitch is a better reason than Snow was
Here's where the film may have an edge over its predecessor. Several critics, including David Rooney at THR, say Haymitch makes for a more poignant origin story than Snow did in Songbirds & Snakes. In our view, Snow was a villain whose backstory explained what we already feared. Haymitch is a man whose backstory explains what we already pitied. That's a stronger bet.
It's also a bet with a built-in problem. The AP review points out that we know Haymitch survives and that the Games he tries to stop go on. So he lives, and fails. Jeopardy gets blunted. The film's answer, per the producer Nina Jacobson in Digital Trends, is to make it about "implicit submission": why the many agree to be ruled by the few. That's a real idea, not just a callback. Whether the film delivers it is another matter. Digital Trends itself says the third act feels rushed, and the Daily Beast's Nick Schager says cramming the book into 158 minutes shortchanges everything.
Still, a prequel about how rebellion can be brought down before it begins is a smarter pitch than "here's how they met." Where the film works, it will be because it treats the known ending as tragedy rather than trivia.
Our verdict: go for Haymitch, ignore the cameo parade
Don't expect greatness. Even the warm reviews, like ComicBook's, say it falls "just short." Expect a handsome, brutal, apparently very sad film (one critic says bring tissues) that is likelier to satisfy fans than convert skeptics.
For the franchise, the lesson is more important than the opening weekend. A big number will probably tempt Lionsgate to keep digging. We'd say the film's own best argument points the other way: a prequel is justified when the character carries it, and the cast of familiar faces is a garnish. If Zada's Haymitch holds the screen, this is a rare prequel with a point. If the reviews that call it a greatest-hits package turn out to be right, the box office will have been the last thing it earned honestly.
Our recommendation: see it for Haymitch, in a theater if you can, and be wary of any sequel pitch that begins with "remember this guy?"
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Depp's Ebenezer won the weekend, not the comeback
A $19 million No. 1 shows audiences will buy a ticket to Depp in a Dickens story, but a solid Christmas bet is not a rehabilitated career. Budget accordingly.
Ramayana's 1,000 crore week: India's epics don't need Hollywood's blessing
Ramayana: Part One reached Rs. 1,000 crore faster than any Indian film, but the numbers say more about India's home market than about a global takeover.
Godzilla Minus Zero shows a local monster can take on Hollywood's machine
A record opening day in Japan and a shot at No. 1 in the U.S. suggest a tightly made, locally rooted kaiju film can out-draw a studio franchise-style event.
A Holmes doc beat Clayface, and DC should read the memo
A low-budget documentary edged a DC villain movie on Halloween weekend. It says less about Clayface than about how audiences now choose what to see in theaters.



