The Body doesn't need saving: the outrage cycle is the real show
A petition with 90,000-plus signatures wants Netflix to cancel a chart-topping teen horror series. We think the platform should ignore the noise and let the show breathe.
AI-generated image
Is there a more reliable marketing campaign for a horror series than a petition demanding its cancellation? Netflix's The Body is topping charts around the world, and a protest movement in the US wants it pulled. We think the two facts are connected, and that Netflix should stay quiet and keep streaming.
A petition against a show that is already winning
The Body follows the dance team of a Catholic school. A recruitment ritual goes badly wrong, and the teenage girls panic that they have summoned supernatural forces. Soon the whole small town is in an uproar. According to Moviepilot, a petition on the platform CitizenGO (reported via Forbes) had gathered more than 90,000 signatures as of November 14. Its backers accuse the series of insulting the Christian faith, and they object to its portrayal of false saints and what they call contempt for belief.
Netflix hasn't commented so far. The numbers, on the other hand, are loud. Per the same report, citing FlixPatrol, the series sits at number one in 13 countries and at number two in Germany.
Outrage is the oldest trailer in the business
Religious horror has always tangled with believers. Provoking them is practically part of the genre's contract. A show about a school, a cult-like dynamic and teenage girls who may or may not have conjured something is going to touch nerves. That is the point of making it.
The cycle is familiar. In controversies like this, a petition appears, the signatures climb, and the coverage does promotional work that a platform's own budget often can't. We can't prove that the petition is driving views for The Body. But a show already number one in 13 countries is clearly not suffering from the controversy. And 90,000 signatures, while not nothing, probably represent a small fraction of the audience a global chart-topper reaches.
There is also a basic mismatch. A petition asks a company to remove something for everyone, based on the objections of people who, in many cases, may not have watched it. A subscriber who finds the premise offensive has a simple remedy: don't press play. Cancellation is a remedy for a problem the petition hasn't shown exists.
The show sounds more careful than its critics claim
Moviepilot's reading of the series is notably more nuanced than the petition's. It describes showrunner Quinn Shephard, previously behind Under the Bridge, as weaving teen drama with religious fervor, black humor, mystery and horror. It says the series keeps viewers guessing whether the forces are supernatural or psychological. And it argues that the series, while critical of the power structures of cults, also acknowledges the comfort and hope faith can offer.
That is one outlet's assessment, and we haven't reviewed the series ourselves, so take it as one critic's view. But if it's accurate, the irony is rich. A series that examines how conviction curdles into hysteria is being met with a petition drive. We'd say that's the show's thesis demonstrating itself.
Netflix should do nothing, and renew it
Our argument is simple. Caving to a campaign against a show that is winning would signal that any organized petition can end a series. That would be bad for every writer pitching anything with an edge.
Moviepilot expects a continuation to be likelier than cancellation. The final seconds reportedly leave room for a second season, though Netflix has neither confirmed nor denied one. That is a forecast, not a fact, but we agree with it. The business logic looks overwhelming.
Our verdict: renew it, say nothing, and let viewers decide. And if you're curious, watch it before signing anything, either way. Judging a show you haven't seen is a close cousin of the snap hysteria the series is said to explore.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
3 Body Problem's long wait is Netflix's own doing, and it's a risk
Season 2 lands January 14, 2027, nearly three years after the premiere. Netflix's prestige sci-fi gamble now depends on whether viewers still care.
Planeswalker must win over people who never opened a booster pack
After seven years of false starts, Netflix's Magic: The Gathering series has a name, a hero and a look. Whether it has a story for outsiders is another matter.
Emily in Paris says goodbye, but will Emily ever change?
A Greek-set final season arriving at Christmas makes for a pretty farewell, but the real test is whether Emily grows up instead of just collecting new postcards.
Blade Runner 2099 must stop selling us the rain and start asking questions
The final trailer promises replicant rule, a sunlit Los Angeles and a human who has lost her humanity. That's a better pitch than neon nostalgia, if the series follows through.



